Thanks to Matt, Tye, Rich, Lance, Caleb, Brian the Designer, and especially Kim The Awesome Girlfriend, 2006 was a kind of live-music renaissance. Honestly, I haven't gone to this many live shows in the course of a year since my days as a Berkeley/San Francisco indie punker. That was nine years ago! This was also the year that I rediscovered an important truth: a live show can make or break a band in the eyes of the viewer. And for every few bands I fell in love with by virtue of their live prowess (Art Brut, Wolfmother, Silversun Pickups, Black Angels), I was totally put off my feed by some genuinely shite performances (Annie, I Love You but I've Chosen Darkness, Kasabian).
So here, in descending order, are the truly superior, eye-watering, scrotum-tightening live experiences of 2006. All venues are in Manhattan, unless otherwise indicated.
1. Daft Punk @ Coachella Valley Music Festival, Indio, California, April 29
2. Art Brut @ Coachella Valley Music Festival, Indio, California, April 30First off, yes, I do realize that having your two favorite shows at a big outdoor festival is contrary to all small-clubs-are-the-best orthodoxy. What can I say? These shows just blew me away! Daft Punk's set was the biggest surprise -- and certainly the most amazing spectacle -- of the year. All of the subsequent (and unanimous) interwebs praise was wholly deserved. Art Brut, on the other hand, was the greatest revelation. No band has ever made so much more
sense to me after a live show. Eddie Argos is the most (strangely) charismatic frontman in rock 'n' roll today. I went from being a fan to being an acolyte in the course of 40 minutes.
3. Flaming Lips @ Hammerstein Ballroom, September 241,500 stoned trust-fund hippies, all with laser-pointers. Before this show, I was pretty sure that was the exact definition of hell. By the time this show/festival/interactive art happening was over, I swear to god I was ready to hug everyone in the room. And I ws on exactly ZERO drugs at the time.
4. Art Brut @ Knitting Factory, May 18More of the same, only with more booze, more energy, more yelling, more sweating, and more MERCH!! Quoth the Kim: "Modern Art... Makes me... WANT TO ROCK OUT!!"
5. Robert Pollard @ Irving Plaza, Apr. 20Bob is probably the most revered indie-rock performer on the planet
if you're a drunk (like him). I am. I hate to admit it, but this was only my second time seeing him, and the first time was in a massive hall where they opened for Cheap Trick. This time I realized how empty my life will be... because I'll never be able to follow GBV around for a year.
6. Black Angels @ Knitting Factory, June 7A redundancy: The Velvet Underground + The Doors + Jesus & Mary Chain... but without any of the Jim Morrison bullshit.
7. Film School @ Mercury Lounge, May 23All I could think was, "How does this lame dude in a baseball cap make such kickass music?" I learned a valuable lesson about books, covers, and judgment.
8. Hot Chip @ Webster Hall, November 2Yea, and the funny-looking British men created much ass-shaking. And lo the hipsters saw that it was good. And there was much rejoicing.
9. Silversun Pickups @ Mercury Lounge, August 3The most charming, self-deprecating, witty stage banter around. Also, sweet guitar solos.
10. Arctic Monkeys @ Webster Hall, March 25Roit! The next wee twat who says the word "hype" gets me boot up their arse!
11. Belle & Sebastian @ Nokia Theater, March 2Stuart was...
dancing!
12. Broken Social Scene @ Prospect Park, Brooklyn, July 6Amy Millan was very, very drunk.
13. Built to Spill @ Warsaw, Greenpoint, Brooklyn, October 3So many Polish beers.
14. The Pipettes @ The Roundhouse, Camden Town, London, December 23So many choreographed dance moves. Definitely the most titillating show I've seen in a while.
15. Danielson @ Northsix, Williamsburg, Brooklyn, May 13Definitely the
least titillating show I've seen all year. A big band of indie-Christians dressed as flight attendants. Again, sounds like a vision of hell on paper, but it was great. And Sufjan stood right behind us.
16. My Morning Jacket @ Roseland Ballroom, November 20I'm still coming to terms with the fact that I like a "jam band." Although in our defense, we never made it through the 20-minute closing guitar solo.